Punished by Rewards?

By Katie Goldsmith | May 2, 2010 | 5 comments

How parents can encourage good behavior in their kids--without making them resentful.

Conventional parenting wisdom presumes that parents should reward their kids’ good behavior with more attention and affection, and punish bad behavior by withholding the same—a way to reinforce the good while discouraging the bad.

But parents, take note: A new study suggests this approach may do more harm than good. Fortunately, the study also finds there’s an effective alternative.

In the study, published in the journal Developmental Psychology, Israeli psychologist Guy Roth examined those positive and negative kinds of parenting attention, as well as a different style, called “autonomy support,” where parents nurture and build their kids’ inner motivation. In the study, 169 ninth graders were given surveys asking about their parents’ parenting style, and how often they hid negative emotions like anger and fear from their parents. They and their teachers also completed another survey about their academic performance. Finally, they filled out a survey to see if they felt any resentment towards their parents.

The results showed that kids who received positive attention from their parents in response to good behavior said they saw the point of the positive behaviors that their parents were trying to promote—but did not necessarily believe in the value of those behaviors themselves. The analysis of their academic performance found that these were the types of kids who focus more on tests and grades than on actually learning—more focused on results than on understanding the important principles behind those results. The kids with parents who used this style also tended to suppress their fear and anger, which is not healthy. 

On the other hand, the study found that the parenting style of withholding affection fosters a lack of motivation among kids. Those kids don’t value parent-approved activities like schoolwork, suggests Roth, because they don’t expect that these activities will help them achieve anything desirable, nor do they feel competent to actually do those activities. This style was also linked to resentment towards parents because the teens viewed them as highly controlling, and kids who received this kind of parenting also weren’t good at controlling their emotions. Both factors have been associated with misbehavior in kids.

The good news is that the study did uncover a helpful alternative for parents. In the second part of the study, giving positive rewards was compared with parental “autonomy support,” where parents explain the reasons for their requests, give their children lots of opportunities to make decisions, encourage but don’t manipulate, and consistently take their child’s perspective into account. This encourages their children to see the intrinsic value of positive behaviors and of learning. 

Roth found that kids who received this type of parenting expressed greater feelings of choice, which predicted more flexible and positive forms of behavior—for instance, getting engaged in academics because they find it interesting, not simply because they feel they have to. In other words, this supportive parenting style was associated with kids actually behaving in positive ways—without the negative emotional consequences linked to other forms of parenting.

“Surely, being supportive of adolescents’ autonomy at times of disagreement is not easy for parents,” writes Roth. “Yet research suggests that, for the sake of children’s psychological and behavioral functioning, it is worthwhile to try.”

Tracker Pixel for Entry

Greater Good wants to know:
Do you think this article will influence your opinions or behavior?

  • Very Likely

  • Likely

  • Unlikely

  • Very Unlikely

  • Not sure

About The Author

Katie Goldsmith is a research assistant at Greater Good.


Like this article?

Here's what you can do:


Can you cite the original article and, if possible link directly to it. When I went to the site you did link to and then searched on “Guy Roth” it did not turn up anything that looked remotely like what you are talking about.

Don Berg | 12:56 pm, May 4, 2010 | Link


This is a great article. Right on track. What needs to be emphasized tho. is that autonomy support STARTS right at toddlerhood. Parents don’t need to wait until the children are at schooling ages.

Sofia | 1:06 pm, May 4, 2010 | Link


Interesting related New York Times article today. A parenting style that relies too heavily on reward & punishment, versus autonomy support, may end in the children cutting off ties with the parents. A growing trend according to this article. Too much punishment = resentment. Too much reward = entitlement.

Sofia | 1:22 pm, May 4, 2010 | Link

Jason Marsh's avatar

Don, the article is:
Roth, et. al., The Emotional and Academic Consequences of Parental Conditional Regard: Comparing Conditional Positive Regard, Conditional Negative Regard, and Autonomy Support as Parenting Practices
Developmental Psychology
2009, Vol. 45, No. 4, 1119–1142

Jason Marsh | 1:43 pm, May 4, 2010 | Link


Thank you for this useful article.  It is also useful for parents to recognize that if they have trouble supporting autonomy by refraining from extrinsic rewards and punishment, they have stumbled upon a wonderful signpost to autonomy issues of their own to work on.  A deeper and broader look at the crippling effects of Punishment by Rewards is the 1993 book by Alfie Kohn titled Punished by Rewards.

Allan Silerthorne, Ph.D. | 4:35 pm, May 19, 2010 | Link

blog comments powered by Disqus



Greater Good Events

The Science of Burnout: What Is It, Why It Happens, and How to Avoid It
International House at UC Berkeley
April 29, 2017
6 CE Hours

The Science of Burnout: What Is It, Why It Happens, and How to Avoid It

A day-long semiar with GGSC Science Director Emiliana Simon-Thomas, Ph.D., celebrated compassion teacher Joan Halifax, burnout expert Christina Maslach, Ph.D., and UCLA psychiatrist Elizabeth Bromley, M.D., Ph.D.


Take a Greater Good Quiz!

How compassionate are you? How generous, grateful, or forgiving? Find out!


Watch Greater Good Videos

Jon Kabat-Zinn

Talks by inspiring speakers like Jon Kabat-Zinn, Dacher Keltner, and Barbara Fredrickson.


Greater Good Resources


Book of the Week

How Pleasure Works By Paul Bloom Bloom explores a broad range of human pleasures from food to sex to religion to music. Bloom argues that human pleasure is not purely an instinctive, superficial, sensory reaction; it has a hidden depth and complexity.

Is she flirting with you? Take the quiz and find out.
"It is a great good and a great gift, this Greater Good. I bow to you for your efforts to bring these uplifting and illuminating expressions of humanity, grounded in good science, to the attention of us all."  
Jon Kabat-Zinn

Best-selling author and founder of the Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction program

thnx advertisement